harm

Skrevet av Emne: "Sokal-spøk" mot alt.med-konferanse  (Lest 1192 ganger)

0 medlemmer og 1 gjest leser dette emnet.

Utlogget Erik Arnesen

  • Innlegg: 1.167
"Sokal-spøk" mot alt.med-konferanse
« på: 10. desember 2010, 17:58:50 »
Morsom anekdote fra siste British Medical Journal, om en medisinprofessor som for moro skyld søkte om å holde et foredrag på The Jerusalem Conference on Integrative Medicine.

Han skulle snakke om en ny "oppdagelse" han hadde gjort; oppdagelsen var bare oppspinn, og sammendraget han sendte inn var med hensikt full av logiske feilslutninger og alternativ-babbel. Gjett hva de svarte?

Integrative medicine and the point of credulity

Sitat
Nationally and internationally, there has been a move to disguise the nature of CAM by renaming it “integrative medicine.” Of course, it is something of an insult to medical practitioners to suggest that they do not take into account their patients’ individuality, autonomy, and views as part of their daily practice. It is certainly a key tenet of evidence based medicine and to suggest that so called integrative medicine is somehow confined to the alternative world is a canard.

Red.: Justerte lenkepålegget.
« Siste redigering: 14. desember 2010, 22:38:48 av Gnisten »
Faced with the choice between changing one's mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everyone gets busy on the proof.

- John Kenneth Gailbrath

Utlogget Erik Arnesen

  • Innlegg: 1.167
Sv: "Sokal-spøk" mot alt.med-konferanse
« Svar #1 på: 11. desember 2010, 17:35:18 »
Nå også omtalt her: http://skepsis.no/blog/?p=5108
Faced with the choice between changing one's mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everyone gets busy on the proof.

- John Kenneth Gailbrath

Utlogget Mr_Tall

  • Innlegg: 169
Sv: "Sokal-spøk" mot alt.med-konferanse
« Svar #2 på: 15. desember 2010, 13:02:36 »
Dukket over følgende på Pharyngula - synes det passer meget bra til denne :)
Sitat
Calvin : I think we have got enough information now, don't you?
Hobbes : All we have is one "fact" that you made up.
Calvin : That's plenty. By the time we add an introduction, a few illustrations and a conclusion, it'll look like a graduate thesis.
Bill Watterson, Calvin & Hobbes
Reality is that which when you stop believing in it doesn't go away.
- Phillip K Dick

Utlogget magnusbe

  • Innlegg: 254
  • leiar i Skepsis
    • twitter
Sv: "Sokal-spøk" mot alt.med-konferanse
« Svar #3 på: 20. desember 2010, 10:59:04 »
Då eg såg overskrifta tenkte eg "jøss, er det nokon som framleis bruker Usenet til anna enn piratnedlasting?".

Utlogget Stephan Brun

  • Innlegg: 2.656
  • ateist, stoiker, filosof, illuminist, mentat.
Sv: "Sokal-spøk" mot alt.med-konferanse
« Svar #4 på: 20. desember 2010, 11:11:26 »
alt.med.konferanse.tull.tull.tull?
cetervm·censeo·carthaginem·stvpiditatem·esse·delendam!
—fritt etter M. Porcivs Cato

Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.
—Charles Mackay.

prvdentia·fortitvdo·ivstitia·temperantia